LETTER: Koczera wrong on auto insurance

Courtesy of SouthCoastToday.com
January 15, 2008 8:40 PM

It is unfortunate that responsible state policymakers continue to rely upon scare tactics and misinformation to oppose the efforts of the Patrick administration to reform the antiquated and anti-consumer Massachusetts auto insurance system. Rep. Robert Koczera's recent op-ed piece ("Auto insurance reform discriminates," Jan. 11) disappointingly relies upon such arguments.

Rep. Koczera is simply wrong that good drivers with spotless records, who are assigned to a company by the Massachusetts assigned risk plan, will not receive the benefits of lower rates. It is illegal for a company to charge such an assigned good driver any more than their policy premium would be were they insured by that company voluntarily.

Rep. Koczera ignores the fact that good drivers in Acushnet, for example, have been subsidizing bad drivers in New Bedford, and vice versa, under the present system, but has not previously found this objectionable.

Driving record is, in fact, a significant factor in the decision all companies make in offering rates, but even staunch opponents of competition in the Legislature acknowledge the impracticality of an auto insurance system based upon a single factor. That said, all the objectionable socioeconomic factors listed by Rep. Koczera have, in fact, been banned for use in determining rates and in underwriting policies.

Real competition, with more companies, more products and more consumer choices, necessitates a regulatory playing field that resembles at least modestly the playing field in the other 49 states of the nation. It is no accident that other big states, like New Jersey and Texas, scrapped their state-set systems in favor of competition and saw more companies compete and better rate offerings across the board.

Consumers can anticipate the same results here in Massachusetts, so long as well-intended but wrong policymakers do not stand in the way of the meaningful reform that the Patrick administration is bringing to the commonwealth's auto insurance system.

James T. Harrington
Executive Director
Massachusetts Insurance Federation
The writer lives in Dartmouth.